The Small AI Test That Tells You More Than a Demo

by Kirk Cole

An AI demo usually starts with a clean example and ends with an impressive answer. Your working day has a few more complications. The document is incomplete. The file has three versions. Someone needs the answer before lunch.

A useful test should look a little more like that working day. It does not need to be large. It needs to tell you whether the tool helps once checking and corrections are included.

Pick a task you can check

Choose one repeatable task with a clear finish line. Turning a short set of meeting notes into an action list is a reasonable starting point. Asking a tool to run your accounting is several decisions disguised as one request.

Use a made-up example or material approved for the tool. Decide in advance what a good answer must contain: the action, the owner if one was named, the due date if one was given, and any open question.

Include an awkward example

Try a clean set of notes, then one with a missing owner, then one with conflicting dates. A tool that produces a tidy list every time might still be making things up. The useful behavior is to flag the missing owner and ask which date is correct.

Here is a prompt worth trying: 'Turn these notes into an action list. Use only the information in the notes. If an owner or date is missing, write not specified. Put conflicting information in a separate questions section.'

Count the whole job

Record the time spent preparing the input, running the task, checking the answer, and fixing it. Compare that with doing the same task manually. A fast first draft can still create a slow finished job.

Keep a short list of errors, too. Did it miss an action? Invent a deadline? Combine two people into one owner? Those details tell you what instructions or review steps need work.

Give the test an ending

Decide whether to use it for this task, revise the instructions and test again, or set it aside. One successful example is a reason to keep evaluating. It is not permission to remove review from a more consequential accounting or tax workflow.

The win is a task that takes less effort to finish correctly. A demo can suggest that possibility. A small, honest test helps you decide whether it is there.